| SEASON |  | MATCH DATE | RESULT | COMP. | ATT. | VENUE |
| 1903-1904 | [+] | 01 Sep 19031903-09-01 | West Ham Utd | 0 - 1 | Argyle | W. League | 4,000 | Memorial Grounds |
| | |
| [+] | 19 Sep 19031903-09-19 | Argyle | 2 - 0 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 16 Jan 19041904-01-16 | West Ham Utd | 1 - 1 | Argyle | S. League | | Memorial Grounds |
| | |
| [+] | 27 Apr 19041904-04-27 | Argyle | 3 - 2 | West Ham Utd | W. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| 1904-1905 | [+] | 09 Nov 19041904-11-09 | Argyle | 2 - 2 | West Ham Utd | W. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 19 Nov 19041904-11-19 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 1 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 06 Mar 19051905-03-06 | West Ham Utd | 1 - 1 | Argyle | W. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 18 Mar 19051905-03-18 | Argyle | 2 - 0 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| 1905-1906 | [+] | 14 Oct 19051905-10-14 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 1 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 29 Nov 19051905-11-29 | Argyle | 3 - 2 | West Ham Utd | W. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 01 Jan 19061906-01-01 | West Ham Utd | 3 - 2 | Argyle | W. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 17 Feb 19061906-02-17 | Argyle | 4 - 2 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| 1906-1907 | [+] | 10 Nov 19061906-11-10 | West Ham Utd | 0 - 0 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 26 Dec 19061906-12-26 | West Ham Utd | 6 - 2 | Argyle | W. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 16 Mar 19071907-03-16 | West Ham Utd | 0 - 0 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 29 Mar 19071907-03-29 | Argyle | 3 - 0 | West Ham Utd | W. League 5,078 | | Home Park |
| | |
| 1907-1908 | [+] | 28 Dec 19071907-12-28 | West Ham Utd | 1 - 1 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 25 Apr 19081908-04-25 | Argyle | 2 - 0 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| 1908-1909 | [+] | 05 Oct 19081908-10-05 | West Ham Utd | 0 - 1 | Argyle | W. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 28 Oct 19081908-10-28 | Argyle | 2 - 1 | West Ham Utd | W. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 05 Dec 19081908-12-05 | Argyle | 2 - 0 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 28 Dec 19081908-12-28 | West Ham Utd | 4 - 0 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1909-1910 | [+] | 23 Oct 19091909-10-23 | West Ham Utd | 4 - 1 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 20 Nov 19091909-11-20 | Argyle | 0 - 0 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| 1910-1911 | [+] | 26 Dec 19101910-12-26 | West Ham Utd | 4 - 0 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 27 Dec 19101910-12-27 | Argyle | 1 - 0 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| 1911-1912 | [+] | 16 Sep 19111911-09-16 | Argyle | 0 - 0 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 20 Jan 19121912-01-20 | West Ham Utd | 0 - 2 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1912-1913 | [+] | 05 Oct 19121912-10-05 | West Ham Utd | 3 - 1 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 08 Feb 19131913-02-08 | Argyle | 0 - 2 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| 1913-1914 | [+] | 04 Oct 19131913-10-04 | Argyle | 3 - 0 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 07 Feb 19141914-02-07 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 1 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1914-1915 | [+] | 05 Dec 19141914-12-05 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 0 | Argyle | S. League | | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 10 Apr 19151915-04-10 | Argyle | 1 - 0 | West Ham Utd | S. League | | Home Park |
| | |
| 1922-1923 | [+] | 24 Feb 19231923-02-24 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 0 | Argyle | FA Cup 3 | 30,525 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1932-1933 | [+] | 24 Dec 19321932-12-24 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 2 | Argyle | Div 2 | 21,312 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 06 May 19331933-05-06 | Argyle | 4 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 10,444 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1933-1934 | [+] | 30 Aug 19331933-08-30 | Argyle | 4 - 4 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 24,312 | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 04 Sep 19331933-09-04 | West Ham Utd | 5 - 1 | Argyle | Div 2 | 16,004 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1934-1935 | [+] | 29 Sep 19341934-09-29 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 1 | Argyle | Div 2 | 20,484 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 09 Feb 19351935-02-09 | Argyle | 0 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 10,841 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1935-1936 | [+] | 19 Oct 19351935-10-19 | Argyle | 4 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 19,140 | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 22 Feb 19361936-02-22 | West Ham Utd | 4 - 2 | Argyle | Div 2 | 19,518 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1936-1937 | [+] | 17 Oct 19361936-10-17 | West Ham Utd | 1 - 1 | Argyle | Div 2 | 28,000 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 20 Feb 19371937-02-20 | Argyle | 2 - 0 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 19,500 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1937-1938 | [+] | 15 Apr 19381938-04-15 | West Ham Utd | 0 - 1 | Argyle | Div 2 | 21,947 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 18 Apr 19381938-04-18 | Argyle | 2 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 21,805 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1938-1939 | [+] | 19 Nov 19381938-11-19 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 1 | Argyle | Div 2 | 25,600 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 25 Mar 19391939-03-25 | Argyle | 0 - 0 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 14,437 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1939-1940 | [+] | 26 Aug 19391939-08-26 | Argyle | 1 - 3 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 Abnd | 18,628 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1945-1946 | [+] | 09 Feb 19461946-02-09 | Argyle | 1 - 2 | West Ham Utd | FL South | 22,394 | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 16 Feb 19461946-02-16 | West Ham Utd | 7 - 0 | Argyle | FL South | 18,000 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1946-1947 | [+] | 31 Aug 19461946-08-31 | Argyle | 3 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 25,659 | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 28 Dec 19461946-12-28 | West Ham Utd | 4 - 1 | Argyle | Div 2 | 24,770 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1947-1948 | [+] | 08 Nov 19471947-11-08 | Argyle | 1 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 29,111 | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 27 Mar 19481948-03-27 | West Ham Utd | 1 - 1 | Argyle | Div 2 | 22,000 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1948-1949 | [+] | 18 Sep 19481948-09-18 | West Ham Utd | 3 - 0 | Argyle | Div 2 | 22,000 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 05 Feb 19491949-02-05 | Argyle | 2 - 0 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 18,494 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1949-1950 | [+] | 03 Sep 19491949-09-03 | Argyle | 0 - 3 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 23,521 | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 31 Dec 19491949-12-31 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 2 | Argyle | Div 2 | 19,000 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1952-1953 | [+] | 27 Sep 19521952-09-27 | Argyle | 1 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 28,154 | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 18 Feb 19531953-02-18 | West Ham Utd | 0 - 1 | Argyle | Div 2 | 8,000 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1953-1954 | [+] | 16 Apr 19541954-04-16 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 2 | Argyle | Div 2 | 16,500 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 19 Apr 19541954-04-19 | Argyle | 2 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 20,938 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1954-1955 | [+] | 18 Sep 19541954-09-18 | Argyle | 1 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 18,370 | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 05 Feb 19551955-02-05 | West Ham Utd | 6 - 1 | Argyle | Div 2 | 18,200 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1955-1956 | [+] | 08 Oct 19551955-10-08 | West Ham Utd | 4 - 0 | Argyle | Div 2 | 19,750 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 31 Mar 19561956-03-31 | Argyle | 0 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 17,555 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1961-1962 | [+] | 11 Sep 19611961-09-11 | West Ham Utd | 3 - 2 | Argyle | FL Cup 1 | 12,178 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+N] | 06 Jan 19621962-01-06 | Argyle | 3 - 0 | West Ham Utd | FA Cup 3 | 27,534 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1962-1963 | [+] | 26 Sep 19621962-09-26 | West Ham Utd | 6 - 0 | Argyle | FL Cup 2 | 9,714 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 1989-1990 | [+] | 26 Aug 19891989-08-26 | West Ham Utd | 3 - 2 | Argyle | Div 2 | 20,231 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+N] | 29 Nov 19891989-11-29 | West Ham Utd | 5 - 2 | Argyle | ZDS Cup 2 | 5,409 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| [+] | 13 Jan 19901990-01-13 | Argyle | 1 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 11,671 | Home Park |
| | |
| 1990-1991 | [+] | 24 Nov 19901990-11-24 | Argyle | 0 - 1 | West Ham Utd | Div 2 | 11,490 | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 05 Mar 19911991-03-05 | West Ham Utd | 2 - 2 | Argyle | Div 2 | 18,933 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 2004-2005 | [+] | 30 Oct 20042004-10-30 | Argyle | 1 - 1 | West Ham Utd | FL Champ | 20,220 | Home Park |
| | |
| [+] | 19 Feb 20052005-02-19 | West Ham Utd | 5 - 0 | Argyle | FL Champ | 25,490 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |
| 2007-2008 | [+] | 26 Sep 20072007-09-26 | West Ham Utd | 1 - 0 | Argyle | FL Cup 3 | 25,774 | The Boleyn Ground, Upton Park |
| | |